Talk:Charms/@comment-112.198.197.115-20130609014101/@comment-484486-20130609200118

From what I understand with challenges is that they have two rewards and you only get one of them based on what you do first. First is a gem reward for doing the challenge without the required weapon, second is a rare charm reward for doing the challenge with the required weapon. So if you did the instance without the weapon during the challenge you will not get the rare charm even if you do it later with the right weapon. Not sure if this is a bug or is intentional.